Our tester pup, a one.5 year previous Golden Retriever, liked this automatic ball launcher. He didn't figure out how to fall the ball into it himself, but nevertheless experienced a great time. The launcher does make some beeping along with other noises indicating which the ball is going to start. https://benitol326dnd2.blogunteer.com/32168083/the-2-minute-rule-for-pet-supplies-plus-doylestown